Wii Save Extractor Error

[eTristan]

Hello, WiiRD community!

I have recently decided to hack my animal crossing city folk town, so I need to extract the save file. When I try to do so, I get an error for some reasoin. My wii is 4.2u system menu, with the latest HBC installed using bannerbomb. My City Folk game is not a backup, and is a US copy. Here is what it says:

Code Select Expand

[*] Insert the game DVD...
Press RESET or A to dump the savegame...
Press POWER or B button to back to the wii system menu

[*] Reading Game Disc... OK!

[*] Identified title: 0001000052555545
[*] Title data directory: /title/00010000/52555545/data

[*] Dumping Savegame data (please wait)... Error! (ret =-1)

[*] Press POWER or B button to back to the wii system menu...

Does it matter that I'm using a wireless Gamecube controller?

My SD card is a Sandisk 4 Gig MicroSDHC with adapter, which I read on GBATemp is a 100% compatible card.

[Link]

The save extractor is a very old homebrew.. it uses an old libogc and cannot handle SDHC cards at all!

[eTristan]

Thank you, I just used my mom's sd card and it worked fine.

But on the side,

are their any good save extractors that do not permanently edit your NAND or require cIOS?

[Link]

Shouldn't the one you use (Waninkoko's) exactly do that.. just copy a savegame?

[eTristan]

One that still takes SDHC and doesnt edit the NAND.

My moms real weird about letting em use her sd card.